EIP-6 Renaming the SUICIDE Opcode (Renaming SUICIDE opcode)
Final · EVM & execution · EIP status Final · created 2015-11-22
This renames the instruction that destroys a contract in the Ethereum programming language from SUICIDE to SELFDESTRUCT. Instead of removing the existing name, the new name is added as an alias.
Why it is needed
Mental health is a very real issue for many people, and even a small change in wording can make a difference. By some estimates, 350 million people worldwide suffer from depression. For someone experiencing loss or depression, it is better not to encounter the word suicide within a programming language. In fact, the Ethereum security audit commissioned by DEVolution, GmbH and conducted by Least Authority also recommended renaming the suicide instruction to a less jarring word such as self-destruct, destroy, terminate, or close, since the name refers to a contract naturally ending its lifetime. This change is meant to show that people matter more than code, and that Ethereum is a mature enough project to recognize the need for change. Since Ethereum is still a young platform, changing it now is less burdensome than changing it later.
What changes
Today
- The instruction that destroys a contract is named SUICIDE
- Developers encounter the word suicide every time they write code
- A security audit report has recommended renaming this instruction
After EIP-6
- SELFDESTRUCT is added as an alias for SUICIDE
- The existing SUICIDE name still works as before, so code already written does not break
- The change is reflected in the Solidity and Serpent languages
Who is affected
- Smart contract developers: The name SELFDESTRUCT can be used when writing new code. Existing code continues to work without modification.
- Language/tooling teams: The alias addition has been reflected in Ethereum programming languages such as Solidity and Serpent.
- The development community: Developers who are experiencing depression or who have lost someone to suicide are exposed to the sensitive word less often.
In depth
Proposal: Adding an Alias Rather Than Replacing the Name
This EIP proposes renaming the SUICIDE opcode to SELFDESTRUCT in Ethereum programming languages. Rather than deleting and replacing SUICIDE, the implementation adds SELFDESTRUCT as an alias for the SUICIDE opcode. As a result, the opcode value and execution behavior at the EVM bytecode level do not change; only the name used at the language surface is added. The source links the actual implementations as a Solidity commit (a8736b7) and a Serpent commit (1106c3b).
Motivation: Mental Health and Ecosystem Growth
The source states that mental health is a real issue for many people and that even small changes in wording can make a difference. By some estimates, 350 million people worldwide suffer from depression, and it explains that someone experiencing loss or depression is better off not seeing the word suicide in a programming language. It also notes that expanding the ecosystem to all types of developers requires frequently reviewing the semantics of the Ethereum programming language. This change is primarily meant to show that people matter more than code, and that Ethereum is a mature enough project to recognize the need for change. It also cites the fact that Ethereum is still a young platform as a reason why changing it early in its life is less burdensome than changing it later.
The Security Audit's Recommendation
The Ethereum security audit commissioned by DEVolution, GmbH and conducted by Least Authority recommended renaming the suicide instruction to a word with less charged connotations, such as self-destruct, destroy, terminate, or close. In particular, it cited the fact that this instruction refers to the natural termination of a contract. This EIP adopted that recommendation and chose the name SELFDESTRUCT.
Standard Classification and Status
This EIP belongs to the Interface category of the Standards Track, since it deals with naming at the programming language level rather than consensus rules. It was created on November 22, 2015, authored by Hudson Jameson, and its current status is Final. Because it is Final, its content is settled and will not change further.