EIP-3267 Routing a Portion of Fees into Future Salaries (Giving Ethereum fees to Future Salaries)
No call decision · Fees & gas · EIP status Stagnant · created 2021-02-13
A proposal to route a portion of transaction and mining fees, along with newly issued ETH, into a Future Salaries contract that distributes them as salaries to public goods producers.
Why it is needed
At present there is no good way to steadily fund developers or researchers who build public goods. Approaches like Quadratic Funding have been tried, but in practice they tend to concentrate on a small number of well-known developers, overlook advanced research that is hard to explain, produce uneven results because of the small number of contributors, and raise amounts too small to meet the demand for public goods. At the same time, there has been ongoing discussion in the Ethereum ecosystem about the need to reduce the amount of ETH in circulation. This proposal tries to solve both problems at once by paying public goods producers out of a portion of fees and newly issued ETH, while simultaneously removing that same amount from circulation.
What changes
Today
- Transaction fees are either burned or go entirely to miners or validators
- Public goods funding relies on approaches like Quadratic Funding, which carry risks of being small-scale and biased
- ETH movement during mining or transfers falls into only two categories: mining rewards or ordinary transactions
After EIP-3267
- On every ETH transfer, a fraction equal to TransferFraction is diverted to a fixed account, and on every mining event, a fraction equal to MineFraction is diverted the same way
- At each set interval, an amount of ETH equal to MintPerPeriod is newly issued and sent into the DonateETH contract
- ETH accumulated in the fixed account is periodically transferred to the DonateETH contract and distributed as salaries to public goods producers through SalaryWithDAO
- Other proposals that burn ETH during transfers or mining conflict with this proposal and must be canceled
Who is affected
- Ordinary users: The circulating supply of ETH held decreases, as a portion is deducted on every transfer and moved into the salary fund.
- Miners and validators: They lose a fraction equal to MineFraction from mining rewards, but the original text argues they benefit indirectly through an increase in ETH's value.
- Public goods producers and DAOs: This is the recipient of ongoing funding distributed as a salary via SalaryWithDAO.
- Other ETH burn proposals: If this EIP is adopted, existing proposals that burn ETH during transfers or mining are to be deprecated.
In depth
All core parameters undetermined
SalaryWithDAO, DefaultDAOInterface, MintPerPeriod, TransferFraction, and MineFraction, all of which appear in the spec, are marked TBD (To Be Decided). Even which addresses to use, what the ratios should be, and how long the issuance period should be have not been decided.
Two funding sources
The salary fund is filled through two channels. One deducts a fixed fraction (TransferFraction, MineFraction) on every ETH transfer or mining event into a fixed account. The other issues new ETH equal to MintPerPeriod at a set interval directly into the DonateETH contract. The amount accumulated in the fixed account is periodically moved back into DonateETH.
The goal is funding public goods and reducing circulating supply
The Rationale states that Future Salaries is the only known way to distribute substantial funding to public goods producers. It points out that quadratic funding as seen on GitCoin tends to concentrate on a small number of developers, overlooks advanced research that is hard to explain, creates incentives for collusion, and yields random results because of the small number of backers, with the total amount raised falling short of the demand for public goods.
Relationship to other burn proposals
The spec states that this proposal should replace other EIPs that burn ETH during transfers or mining. It also notes that the amount distributed under this proposal must exceed what would have been burned under previously approved burn-related proposals, though exactly how much more is left as TBD.
Backwards compatibility concerns
Transfers to the fixed account constitute a new kind of ETH movement that is neither a mining reward nor an ordinary transaction. The original text states that this may affect applications that have assumed ETH transfers occur only as either miner rewards or transactions.
Security considerations
There is a risk that the DAO controlling SalaryWithDAO could shift to an inefficient or biased voting scheme and distribute funds unfairly. The original text states that this problem can only be resolved by 'confiscating' the DAO's control through a future fork.
Current status
This proposal is in Stagnant status, and the core values and contract addresses in the spec all remain TBD, so no concrete implementation has been finalized. The provided call records show no decision on whether to include this proposal in a fork.