EIP-3143 Raising the block reward to 5 ETH (Increase block rewards to 5 ETH)

No call decision · Consensus & staking · EIP status Stagnant · created 2020-12-01

A proposal to raise the per-block reward paid to proof-of-work (PoW) miners from 2 ETH to 5 ETH, and to increase uncle and nephew rewards by the same proportion.

Why it is needed

At the time, the block reward was 2 ETH, and since transaction fees made up a significant portion of the reward, total mining revenue dropped sharply when fees were low. Because miners always try to mine whichever coin is most profitable at a given moment, periods of low fees caused them to redirect hardware to other coins, weakening Ethereum's network security (hashpower). Restoring the block reward to 5 ETH, its level early in the network's life, reduces the volatility of how much of the total reward comes from fees and gives miners a stronger economic incentive to mine Ethereum. The logic also holds that if miners accumulate more ETH through rewards, they will already have the ETH needed to become validators once the network later transitions to proof-of-stake (PoS, ETH 2.0), making the switch to being a validator easier and creating an incentive to hold ETH rather than sell it during the transition period, reducing sell pressure and preserving network security.

What changes

Today

After EIP-3143

Who is affected

In depth

Block reward formula

new_block_reward is 5_000_000_000_000_000_000 wei (5E18 wei, 5 ETH) if block.number is greater than or equal to FORK_BLKNUM, and otherwise keeps the existing block.reward (the prior 2 ETH) unchanged. In other words, this is a conditional change that only swaps the reward value based on the fork block number, while the calculation logic itself stays the same as before.

Uncle reward adjustment

When an included uncle block satisfies block.number - uncle.number = k, new_uncle_reward is calculated as (8 - k) * new_block_reward / 8. This keeps the structure of the existing uncle reward formula intact, simply substituting new_block_reward (5 ETH) for the old block_reward value.

Nephew reward adjustment

The nephew reward is calculated as new_nephew_reward = new_block_reward / 32. As with the uncle reward, this substitutes the new value (5 ETH) in place of block_reward in the existing nephew reward formula, reusing the existing formula as is without any new logic.

Basis for the 5 ETH figure

The original Rationale explains that 5 ETH was chosen as a middle ground between not raising the inflation rate too much and making it easier for miners to accumulate the ETH needed to transition to PoS validators through PoW mining. At 5 ETH, the first-year annual inflation rate is put at about 10.4%.

Motivation for the proposal

The Motivation section points out that transaction fees sometimes approach or exceed the block reward (2 ETH), causing high reward volatility, and that when fees are low, miners shift to other coins, weakening network security. It explains that raising the reward to 5 ETH would reduce this volatility and let miners use the ETH they accumulate to reduce sell pressure during the PoS transition while creating an incentive to become validators.

Compatibility, security, and current status

The original text states that both Backwards Compatibility and Security Considerations have no known issues. However, this EIP's status is Stagnant, meaning discussion on the proposal has stalled. It has not yet been adopted or included in a fork, and the call records contain no decision about fork inclusion either.

Original EIP · ← EIPs