Should Ethereum split forks into smaller scopes and ship them more often?

Governance & community · 10 participants · 13 quotes · 2026-11-20 ~ 2026-11-20

When the Glamsterdam delay pushed back features like contract size expansion, app developers such as lex_node and sakulstra called for shipping smaller forks more frequently or shipping a lead fork containing only quality-of-life (QOL) features first. Core developers including lightclients and CPerezz19 agreed smaller forks ship faster but pushed back on the practicality, citing the cost of scope cuts, retesting, and the bottleneck of protocol understanding.

Background

Glamsterdam is the largest hard fork to date, bundling over 20 EIPs including ePBS, BALs, and EIP-8037. It originally targeted mainnet in early 2026, but a problem surfaced where EIP-8037 breaks invariants of already-deployed contracts, pushing the earliest mainnet date to mid-January 2027. According to nero_eth's analysis, every fork since Dencun has taken more than 400 days from scope finalization to mainnet, but Glamsterdam targeted the shortest timeline yet at 320 days. Pectra split its fork and Fusaka dropped EOF at the last minute, but Glamsterdam reached testnet while keeping nearly all its EIPs, and even after the public testnet there were 10 further spec changes over six weeks.

Why it matters

The tension between app developers' demand for faster shipping and the limits of core developers' review and comprehension capacity could change how scope is decided for the next fork and the practice of agreeing on cut dates in advance. This connects to the roadmap prioritization debate, since prolonged contract size constraints increase app developers' incentive to migrate to their own L2s.

Key points

For — Split forks into smaller scopes and ship more often

sakulstra, _gabrielShapir0, cyp.eth, Łukasz Rozmej, Philastru

Against — It's impossible, or actually more work

ً, 0xRahul, CPerezz.eth ⟠ 🦀

Neutral — Smaller forks do ship faster, but scope cuts and comprehension are the bottleneck

Toni Wahrstätter ⟠

Other — Delay doesn't matter, only uptime matters

hammundi7

← Debates